Performing Arts Skills

Crafting Subtext




Crafting subtext is a powerful way to add emotional depth and complexity to your scene. Subtext is what your character is thinking, feeling, or hiding beneath their words. It allows for nuance and makes the audience feel the tension without everything being explicitly said. Below is a guide to crafting effective subtext, along with examples tailored to the Lila confronts Arden betrayal scene.

1. Understanding Subtext

Subtext happens when:
1. A character’s words don’t align with their feelings.
- Example: Saying, “I’m fine” when they’re clearly hurt.
2. A character avoids saying what they truly mean.
- Example: Using sarcasm or humor to mask fear or vulnerability.
3. Tension exists between characters, but it’s unspoken.
- Example: A long silence that communicates anger or hesitation.

2. Crafting Subtext Step by Step

Step 1: Identify the Surface Dialogue

Start with what the character says. Surface dialogue is the literal text spoken aloud.

Example:
Lila: "I trusted you!"

Step 2: Define the Subtext

Decide what the character is truly feeling or thinking behind the words. Subtext often reflects hidden emotions, motives, or fears.

Subtext for Lila:
- “I thought you were family. You were the one person I believed in, and you destroyed that.”

Step 3: Use Actions, Tone, or Pauses

Subtext often comes to life through how the line is delivered. Combine tone, physicality, and pacing to reveal what the character isn’t saying.

Subtext in Performance:
- Lila yells “I trusted you!” but her voice cracks, showing that the anger is fueled by hurt.
- She avoids eye contact, as if she can’t bear to see Arden’s reaction, and clutches a personal object tied to their relationship (e.g., a token of trust).

3. Techniques for Crafting Subtext

A. Use Contradictions

Characters often say one thing while meaning another, especially when emotions are high. This creates rich subtext.

  • Example:
  • Surface Dialogue: “I don’t care anymore.”
  • Subtext: “I care so much, but it hurts too much to admit it.”

B. Add Layers of Emotion

Most emotional moments are complex. Layer different emotions to create tension in the subtext.

  • Example (Lila confronts Arden):
  • Surface Dialogue: “Just tell me why you did it.”
  • Subtext: “I’m hoping there’s a good reason—something that will make this hurt less.”

C. Use Silence

Subtext thrives in what’s not said. A pause, hesitation, or meaningful look can say more than words.

  • Example:
  • Lila: (long pause, staring at Arden) "You don’t even have an excuse, do you?"
  • Subtext: “The fact that you’re not answering confirms my worst fears.”

D. Include Deflection or Evasion

When characters avoid addressing the truth directly, their subtext becomes even more apparent.

  • Example:
  • Arden: “I didn’t have a choice.”
  • Subtext: “I did have a choice, but admitting that makes me the villain.”

E. Use Objects or the Environment

Subtext can also emerge through how a character interacts with their surroundings.

  • Example:
  • Lila clutches a necklace Arden gave her as a gift, staring at it before throwing it on the ground.
  • Subtext: “You broke my trust, so this means nothing to me anymore.”

4. Examples of Subtext in Dialogue

Lila’s Confrontation

Surface Dialogue:

  • "You’ve been working with them all this time, haven’t you?"

Subtext:

  • “Please say I’m wrong. Please tell me I didn’t misjudge you this badly.”

Surface Dialogue:

  • “Was I just some pawn in your plan?”

Subtext:

  • “I need to know that I mattered to you, even if you betrayed me.”

Arden’s Responses

Surface Dialogue:

  • "It’s not that simple."

Subtext:

  • “I don’t want to admit I chose my own survival over your trust.”

Surface Dialogue:

  • “I never wanted to hurt you.”

Subtext:

  • “I knew this would destroy you, but I did it anyway, and I hate myself for it.”

5. Balancing Subtext and Text

While subtext adds depth, the spoken words must still carry weight. The audience should sense what’s beneath the surface without being confused. Here’s how to strike a balance:

  1. Key Moments of Explicitness: Let the character break through their subtext at climactic points.

  2. Example: Lila finally says, “I trusted you more than anyone, and now I don’t know if I’ll ever trust anyone again.”

  3. Use Subtext Sparingly for Impact: Too much subtlety can dilute the tension. Alternate between subtext and direct statements to keep the scene dynamic.

  4. Example:
    • Lila: (quietly) “How could you?” (subtext: I’m devastated.)
    • Lila: (shouting) “You were supposed to protect me!” (explicit emotional outburst).

6. Layering Subtext in the Scene

Let’s combine dialogue, subtext, and physicality into a short excerpt from the Lila and Arden scene.

Scene Excerpt: Confrontation

Lila:
(Quietly, avoiding eye contact) “I heard something about you today. Something ridiculous. Tell me it’s not true.”
(Subtext: I don’t want to believe this. I need you to reassure me.)

Arden:
(Voice low, glancing away) “You shouldn’t believe everything you hear.”
(Subtext: I’m deflecting because I know you’ve figured it out.)

Lila:
(Stepping closer, voice rising) “I’m not an idiot, Arden! The reports, the ambushes, all of it—it was you, wasn’t it?”
(Subtext: Admit it so I can stop torturing myself with the possibility that I’m wrong.)

Arden:
(Desperately) “I didn’t have a choice, Lila!”
(Subtext: I made my decision, but I hate facing the consequences.)

Lila:
(Voice cracking, clutching a necklace Arden gave her) “No, you had a choice. You just didn’t choose me.”
(Subtext: I gave you everything, and you threw it away.)

Arden:
(Softly, head down) “I thought I was doing what was best—for both of us.”
(Subtext: I don’t even believe this excuse, but it’s all I have.)

Lila:
(Steps back, straightens her posture) “Then I guess we’re done here.”
(Subtext: I’m walking away, but it’s breaking me inside.)

❤ If you liked this, consider supporting us by checking out Tiny Skills - 250+ Top Work & Personal Skills Made Easy